All posts

How to answer BEST and PRIMARY questions on CISA

By Chidambaram Narayanan, , 3 min read

BEST questions are where good candidates lose the most marks.

Because there’s rarely a bad option. You’re choosing between good and best.

PRIMARY questions are their close cousin: four true statements, and you have to pick the main one.

Let’s take them one at a time.


BEST: the best overall choice

When a question asks for the BEST action, control, recommendation or approach, run each option through three checks.

1. Does it fix the cause, or just this case? Disabling 12 leavers’ accounts fixes today. Linking account removal to HR leaver records fixes it for good. The cause wins.

2. Does it fit the auditor’s role? The auditor evaluates, recommends and reports. Management decides and implements. An option where the auditor implements, approves or owns a control is almost never BEST.

3. Is it complete and practical? The ideal answer in a perfect world (hire more staff, buy a new system) often loses to the realistic one that actually addresses the risk in the situation described.

Exam reality: BEST is the option that would still be the right call if your audit manager asked you to defend it.


An example

In a small IT team of three, the same administrator develops program changes and moves them into production. Hiring more staff is not possible. What is the BEST compensating control?

  • A. Ask the administrator to sign a code of conduct
  • B. Have a manager independently compare production changes with approved change requests each month
  • C. Turn on logging of all changes to production
  • D. Separate development and production duties

Answer: B.

  • A is a promise, not a check.
  • C creates data, but a log nobody reviews controls nothing.
  • D is the ideal fix, and the scenario rules it out.
  • B is independent, regular and checks what was actually done.

PRIMARY: the main purpose

PRIMARY, MAIN and KEY ask why something exists.

Every option is usually a true benefit. Only one is the reason it was created.

Ask: “If this thing didn’t achieve that one result, would it still be worth having?”

  • Audit charter: to establish audit’s authority and independence. Not to schedule audits.
  • Audit universe: to make sure no significant area is missed when risks are ranked. Not to set the budget.
  • Control self-assessment: to make management own its controls. Not to cut audit costs.
  • Continuous auditing: to find problems sooner. Not to prevent fraud.
  • Closing meeting: to confirm the facts and agree the findings. Not to present to the board.

The other options are side benefits. Real, but secondary.

Exam reality: Options about cost savings, efficiency or “satisfying the external auditor” are usually side benefits, not the PRIMARY purpose.


Two related red words

MOST reliable / BEST evidence. Ask who produced it. Evidence the auditor obtains directly, from an independent source, beats anything the auditee hands over. A bank confirmation sent straight to the auditor beats a printout from the finance system.

MOST effective. Ask what actually achieves the goal. Stopping a problem usually beats catching it later, as long as the preventive control really addresses the risk in the question.


Practice drill

For your next 15 BEST questions, score each option against the three checks: fixes the cause, fits the auditor’s role, practical. The answer is usually the only one that passes all three.

For PRIMARY questions, cover the options and write the purpose in five words first. Then find the option that matches.

Tomorrow, the final part: the error log, the habit that turns every wrong answer into marks on exam day.