All posts

How to answer FIRST and NEXT questions on CISA

By Chidambaram Narayanan, , 3 min read

FIRST and NEXT questions cause more wrong answers than any other type on CISA.

Not because they’re hard.

Because candidates answer the wrong question: they pick the most important action instead of the earliest one.


FIRST is about time, not importance

When a question asks what the auditor should do FIRST, every option is usually something the auditor will do at some point.

Report it? Yes, eventually. Recommend a fix? Yes, eventually. Test it? Yes, eventually.

The question is only: which comes before the others?

Exam reality: The most important action is often the last step. FIRST questions punish people who jump to the end.


Step 1: Work out where you are

Before reading the options, place the scenario on the audit timeline:

  • Planning: before fieldwork starts
  • Fieldwork: testing, gathering evidence
  • Reporting: findings are known, the report is being prepared
  • Follow-up: the report is out, actions are being tracked

Then ask: “What’s the very next step from here?”


Step 2: Use the default sequence

Across most CISA scenarios, the auditor’s natural order is:

Understand → Identify risks → Confirm → Evaluate → Report → Follow up

So in each phase, FIRST usually looks like this:

  • Planning: understand the area and its risks. Not test, not review logs, not recommend.
  • Found something during fieldwork: confirm it’s real and how big it is. Not report it yet, not fix it.
  • Auditee disputes a finding: recheck your own evidence. Not remove the finding, not escalate yet.
  • Conflict of interest: tell your audit manager before you start. Not handle it yourself.
  • Possible fraud: gather enough evidence to decide whether an investigation is needed. Not confront anyone.

An example

During an audit of change management, the IS auditor finds that 4 of 30 sampled changes to the billing system have no approval record. What should the auditor do FIRST?

  • A. Report the finding to the IT director
  • B. Expand the sample to see how widespread the problem is
  • C. Find out whether the 4 changes were emergency changes approved after the event
  • D. Recommend that all changes require approval before release

Answer: C.

  • A jumps to reporting before the finding is confirmed.
  • B is a sensible step, but only once you know the 4 are real exceptions.
  • D jumps to the recommendation.
  • C checks whether there’s an explanation, such as emergency changes approved afterwards, which is the first step in confirming the finding.

The three FIRST traps

1. Jumping ahead. Picking report, recommend or conclude before understanding or confirming. The most common trap by far.

2. Fixing it yourself. The auditor doesn’t remove access, change settings or rewrite procedures. If an option has the auditor fixing the problem, cross it out.

3. Asking the wrong person. The person being audited can’t decide audit matters, and the board doesn’t pick individual tests. Check whose decision it is.


What about NEXT?

NEXT works the same way, but the scenario tells you what has already been done.

Read carefully: “The auditor has confirmed that the exceptions are real. What should the auditor do NEXT?”

Understanding and confirming are already done, so the answer moves one step along: usually evaluate the impact or extent, then report.

Exam reality: With NEXT, cross out every option the scenario says is already done. Then pick the earliest remaining step.


Practice drill

For your next 20 practice questions with FIRST or NEXT:

  1. Write down the phase: planning, fieldwork, reporting or follow-up.
  2. Write down the next step from the default sequence before reading the options.
  3. Then find the option that matches.

If you get one wrong, note which trap caught you: jumping ahead, fixing it yourself or wrong person. You’ll use that in Part 5, on the error log.

Tomorrow, Part 3: MOST and GREATEST questions, and how to pick the problem that causes the others.