All posts

Read the red word first: how to answer FIRST, MOST and BEST questions on CISA

By Chidambaram Narayanan, , 3 min read

Here’s something nobody tells you when you start CISA:

Most questions have two answers that are correct.

Not “sort of correct”. Genuinely correct. Things an auditor might really do.

So the exam isn’t asking “which of these is right?”

It’s asking “which of these is right for this exact question?”

And the thing that decides it is usually one small word.


The words that decide the answer

I call them the red words, because when I teach, I underline them in red.

  • FIRST / NEXT: what comes earliest in time
  • MOST / GREATEST: which problem or factor matters most
  • BEST / MOST appropriate: the best overall choice
  • PRIMARY / MAIN / KEY: the main purpose or reason
  • MOST reliable / BEST evidence: the proof you can trust most
  • MOST effective: what actually achieves the goal

Each one asks a different question, even when the scenario and the options are identical.


One scenario, three different answers

An IS auditor reviewing user access finds that 12 people who left the company months ago still have active accounts on the payroll system.

Options:

  • A. Report the finding to senior management
  • B. Confirm with HR that the 12 people have actually left
  • C. Recommend that account removal is triggered automatically by HR leaver records
  • D. Review system logs for any activity on the 12 accounts after their leaving dates

Now change the red word:

  • What should the auditor do FIRST? → B. Confirm the finding is real before anything else.
  • What is the MOST reliable evidence that the accounts were misused? → D. System logs, gathered by the auditor, show what actually happened.
  • What is the BEST recommendation? → C. It fixes the cause, not just these 12 accounts.

And A? Reporting is right too, eventually. It’s just not the answer to any of these three questions.

Same facts. Three questions. Three different correct answers.

Exam reality: If you read the scenario and jump to the options, you’ll pick an answer that’s right for a question they didn’t ask.


The habit that fixes it

Before you look at the options, do two things:

1. Find the red word. Circle it in your head.

2. Say the question in plain words.

  • FIRST → “What’s the very next step from where we are?”
  • GREATEST → “Which problem hurts the most?”
  • BEST → “Which choice fixes the cause and fits the auditor’s job?”
  • PRIMARY → “Why does this thing exist?”

Only then read the options.

It feels slow at first. After about 100 questions it becomes automatic, and it’s the single biggest jump in scores I see.


Three more things to watch for

Who is doing it? The auditor checks, confirms and reports. Management fixes. If an option has the auditor fixing the problem, it’s almost always a trap.

When is it happening? Planning, fieldwork and reporting have different “first” steps. The same red word gives a different answer in each phase.

No red word? Then the question is testing knowledge. Recall the concept and answer directly. Don’t overthink it.


What’s coming in this series

Over the next four days, one post a day:

  1. Read the red word first (this post)
  2. FIRST and NEXT questions: finding where you are in the process
  3. MOST and GREATEST questions: picking the problem that causes the others
  4. BEST and PRIMARY questions: the best overall choice, and the main purpose
  5. The error log: the habit that turns wrong answers into marks

Try it now: Take 10 practice questions today. Before reading the options, write down the red word and what it’s really asking. Check how many you’d have got wrong by skipping that step.

If you want to practise this exact habit, the free Build your auditor mindset drill makes you name what each question is asking before you answer.